Doctrinal criteria

• PRESCRIPTION OF THE RIGHT TO CLAIM

1. General considerations. Deadline
2. Starting day of the term
3. Interruption of the limitation period
4. restrictive interpretation

• REPRESENTATION

1. Introduction
2. Lack of representation accreditation
3. Representation of communities of owners
4. legal representations
5. Favorable criterion (pro actione)

• GENERAL REQUIREMENTS OF LIABILITY

1. Introduction
2. The damage
3. Title of imputation. Normal or abnormal operation of public services
4. causal relationship
5. Liability Exemption Factors
6. Unlawfulness of the damage

• Information

1. Considerations
2. The report of the service causing the damage
3. The health inspection report

• TEST

1. Considerations
2. Burden of proof
3. Admission and inadmissibility of evidence
4. The different means of proof
5. test evaluation

• CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSIBILITY

1. Introduction
2. Works and public works concession contracts
3. Public service and service management contracts
4. supply contracts

• DAMAGE ASSESSMENT

1. Introduction
2. Valuation criteria
3. Timing of Valuation

----

Prepared by Carlos Yáñez Díaz and Eduardo Pflueger Tejero, Lawyers of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions:

Prescription: 439/11, 571/11, 726/11; Representation: 641/11, 156/12, 570/12, 298/13;

General requirements: 14/12, 40/12, 93/12, 330/12; Reports: 53/11, 610/11, 273/12;

Proof: 166/08, 307/11, 375/11, 612/12; Contractor Responsibility: 278/12, 336/12, 379/13;

Damage assessment: 61/10, 93/12

Update date: October 31, 2014

PATRIMONIAL RESPONSIBILITY. SANITARY FIELD

• Introduction
• Passive legitimation. Title of imputation: the competition

1. Concerted health centers
2. Patients referred from other autonomous communities
3. Work mutuals or collaborating entities
4. Other cases

• lex artis

1. Adaptation to protocols
2. Obligation of means, not of result
3. Curative medicine and satisfying medicine
4. disproportionate damage
5. Nosocomial infections
6. biomedical research
7. development risks

• opportunity loss
• Informed consent

1. How to give consent
2. Content of the informed consent document
3. Incomplete informed consent document
4. Absence of informed consent

----

Prepared by Esther de Alba Bastarrechea, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions:

Passive legitimation: 175/14;

Lex artis: 611/11, 535/12, 18/13, 34/13, 52/13, 165/14, 176/14, 380/14, 393/14, 427/14;

Opportunity Loss: 226/12, 195/13, 241/14, 397/14;

Informed consent: 384/11, 483/11, 207/12, 96/14, 226/14, 279/14, 45/13, 37/13

Update date: October 31, 2014

PATRIMONIAL RESPONSIBILITY. ROAD SCOPE

• Introduction
• Falls on public roads

1. passive standing
2. Causal relationship: Proof. test media. Rupture of the causal link. Concurrence of faults
3. Unlawfulness of the damage
4. casuism

• traffic accidents

1. passive standing
2. Causal relationship: Proof. test media. Rupture of the causal link.
3. Unlawfulness of the damage
4. casuism

----

Prepared by Ana Sofía Sánchez San Millán, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions:

Falls on public roads: 180/08, 138/11, 749/11, 41/12, 152/12, 186/13

Traffic accidents: 179/08, 292/09, 6/11, 228/11, 13/13

Update date: October 31, 2014

PATRIMONIAL RESPONSIBILITY. LABOR SPHERE

• Introduction
• Patrimonial responsibility derived from work accidents

1. Active legitimation
2. passive standing
3. Calculation of term to claim
4. Fund budgets of the right to compensation
5. Compensable damages

• Patrimonial responsibility for mobbing

1. Active legitimation
2. passive standing
3. Prescription
4. General considerations about workplace harassment
5. Modalities
6. Specific budgets of application of the figure
7. Burden of proof
8. Inadequacy of the path of patrimonial responsibility in cases of workplace harassment

----

Prepared by Ana del Pino Carazo, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 66/08, 140/10, 377/12

Update date: October 31, 2014

PATRIMONIAL RESPONSIBILITY. RELATED TO SCHOOL

• Introduction
• Accidents produced in the school

1. Accidents affecting center staff
2. Accidents involving students
3. Accidents that affect third parties outside the educational center

• Aggressions between students
• Assumptions of harassment between students in the school environment (bullying)
• Corrective or disciplinary files for students
• Sanctions for teachers
• Denial of access to school places

----

Prepared by Ana del Pino Carazo, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 429/09, 11/10, 140/10, 151/10, 235/10, 520/11, 155/12

Update date: October 31, 2014

PATRIMONIAL RESPONSIBILITY. INACTIVITY OF THE ADMINISTRATION

• Introduction
• Inactivity of the Public Administration. General features
• The damage

1. Damage Characteristics
2. damage proof

• Injurious act and imputation of the damage
• Unlawfulness of the damage
• causal relationship
• Damage assessment. Economic Evaluability

----

Prepared by Elena Bilbao Alexiades, Deputy Secretary of the Board.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 290/09, 8/10, 151/12, 314/13, 346/14

Update date: July 31, 2015

• Introduction
• Legal nature
• Regulations applicable to the powers of the Administration
• Competent bodies to agree on the interpretation, modification and resolution
• Interpretation of contracts
• Modification of contracts
• Termination of contracts
• Term and expiration of interpretation, modification and resolution procedures
• Nullity of contracts
• Administrative concessions

----

Prepared by Rocío Guerrero Ankersmit, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 417/12, 511/12, 515/12, 241/13, 268/13

Update date: October 31, 2014

• The regulatory power of the Administration
• The law-regulation relationship
• The autonomous regulation in the jurisdictional framework of the State
• The different types of regulations: decrees and orders of the councilors
• The procedure for drawing up the regulations

1. The agreement to initiate the procedure
2. Hearing and public information
3. Reports to collect in the procedure
4. The regulatory impact report
5. The opinion of the Advisory Council. function and content

• Normative technique in the elaboration of regulatory norms

----

Prepared by Carlos Yáñez Díaz, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document

Update date: October 31, 2014

• Introduction
• Procedure for review of provisions and acts null and void

1. Law
2. Procedures: Start. Instruction. Termination

• Budgets for ex officio review

1. Reviewable administrative acts
2. Reviewable administrative provisions

• Causes of nullity
• Review Limits

1. Over time
2. Other circumstances

• Compensatory effects

----

Prepared by Ana del Pino Carazo, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 497/09, 742/11, 284/13

Update date: October 31, 2014

• Introduction
• Only against firm acts in administrative proceedings
• Extraordinary nature of the appeal
• Causes

1. Error of fact resulting from the documents included in the file
2. Documents of essential value unknown at the time the appealed decision was issued

• Compensation claims

----

Prepared by Esther de Alba Bastarrechea, Lawyer of the Council.

Download document
Featured Opinions: 22/08, 38/09, 192/09, 327/09, 60/14, 139/14, 399/14, 411/14

Update date: October 31, 2014